Section 16 Exit Reporting

Last week, I covered the ground rules for Section 16 exit reporting. This week, I have a few more pointers on the topic.

Best Practices

I’ve already covered a couple of best practices: whenever insiders cease to be subject to Section 16, review their transactions for the year for any that haven’t been reported and file a Form 4 to report these transactions at that time, rather than waiting until the end of the year, when you are more likely to forget about them. Also, be sure to include these former insiders in your year-end surveys and reconciliations for Section 16 (and obtain a “no Form 5 due” statement from them).

It’s also a good idea to review their transactions for the past six months for any non-exempt transactions. Count out six months from their last non-exempt purchase and that tells you how long they need to report non-exempt sales. Then count out six months from their last non-exempt sale to determine the last date they need to report non-exempt purchases. Inform former insiders of these dates, so they are aware that their non-exempt transactions are still subject to Section 16, both for reporting purposes and short-swing profits recovery purposes. If the company will continue to assist with their post-Section 16 reporting, you may want to make a note of these dates in your calendar as well.

The Exit Box

Both Form 4 and Form 5 include a checkbox to indicate that the reporting person is no longer subject to Section 16, commonly referred to as the “exit box.” Any time a new form is submitted after an insider is no longer subject to Section 16, whether to report newly occurring non-exempt transactions that are still reportable or to report previously unreported transactions, this box should be selected.

Who Is Responsible for Post-Termination Reporting?

Section 16 imposes an obligation on the individual insider, but, as my readers well know, most companies assist their officers and directors with this obligation by preparing and submitting the required forms on their behalf. And my guess is that this continues to be the case during that short period where the individual has ceased to be a designated insider but is still subject to the reporting and short-swing profits recovery provisions of Section 16.

I would certainly expect this to be the case if the individual is still employed by the company but has merely experienced a reduction in responsibility (no sense in adding insult to injury by making them take on their own Section 16 filings). But, even in the case of former insiders that have terminated their employment, the company probably still submits their Section 16 filings for them. The exception might be where an insider has left on bad terms, e.g., was dismissed for some sort of egregious behavior or violated a non-compete or other agreement. In that case, some companies might leave the offending insider to his/her own devices for Section 16 purposes (and be happy to disclose a reporting violation and recover profits in the event that the insider doesn’t manage the obligation sufficiently).

What About Form 144?

Most Section 16 insiders are also considered affiliates of the company and are required to sell under Rule 144. They are subject to Rule 144 by virtue of the authority they possess over the company. If they no longer possess this authority, then they also should no longer be subject to Rule 144 (unless, of course, they hold unregistered shares). But when exactly does Rule 144 no longer apply?

Although the determination should be made based on the relevant facts and circumstances, the Rule 144 experts we look to here at the NASPP–Jesse Brill, Bob Barron, and Alan Dye–generally believe that, in most cases where individuals have cut all ties to the company, they cease to be subject to Rule 144 when their employment ends. A recent SEC interpretation, however, suggests that it is a good idea for former affiliates to sell under Rule 144 for three months or until the company files its next periodic report and many companies have implemented similar policies.

Got Questions on Section 16?
Alan Dye has the answers. Tune in later today for his popular, annual Q&A webcast on Section 16.

Quick Survey on Section 6039
Take our Quick Survey on Section 6039 and learn how companies are planning to comply with this new tax reporting requirement. A mere seven questions–you can complete the survey in less than five minutes!

ShareComp 2011
The NASPP is happy to announce its support of ShareComp 2011, a fully virtual conference on stock compensation. NASPP members can attend the event for free using the sponsor pass “VCP”; feel free to share this sponsor code with others at your company.

ShareComp 2011 will be held live on February 23, 2011 and all presentations, documents, and booths will be available on-demand for a year afterwards. More than just a series of webinars, ShareComp is a 3-D rendered environment with all of the features of a physical conference, without the cost and time of travel. Benefits of attending include:

16 hours of live global interactive learning and networking
Best practices for designing, implementing and managing stock compensation programs
Instructional sessions that will share real-world examples, tactics and lessons learned
Facilitated discussion forums with experts and practitioners
A searchable library, including presentations, Q&A sessions and booth materials
A year of access to the conference center and materials

To find out more, visit ShareComp2011.com. Register today for this no-risk, high-impact event (be sure to enter sponsor pass “VCP” for free registration). While you are attending the event, we hope you’ll stop by the NASPP virtual booth to say hello.

NASPP “To Do” List
We have so much going on here at the NASPP that it can be hard to keep track of it all, so I keep an ongoing “to do” list for you here in my blog.